There is a strong consensus in the United States that the system of higher education is broken. The exact dimensions of the brokenness, root causes, and solutions are matters of considerable debate, but I am confident that few people would agree that absolutely nothing in the system should change. In The Tyranny of Merit, Michael J. Sandel addresses a bedrock assumption of our culture: merit is the correct way to distribute success. Specifically, merit is determined through economic contributions and market outcomes, and success is defined by consumption and social esteem. Framed in the context of how we arrived at our current reality, Sandel looks for structural causes of social division and populist resentment. The current system of higher education is both symptom and cause of the problem the author identifies.
Over the course of the book, Sandel develops the argument that a belief in meritocracy leads to the dissolution of social bonds and the common good. It does so via three mechanisms: the connection of merit and morality, an inflated sense of an individual’s role in accomplishments, and the erosion of social esteem derived from work. The author focuses on changes in political discourse around education, merit, markets, and welfare over the past 40 to 50 years, drawing examples from across the political spectrum. While the focus is clearly on the United States, Sandel cites evidence from other countries to highlight similarities and differences in cultural beliefs.
While the term meritocracy is relatively new, the underlying concept has been guiding humanity in various dimensions for millennia. Sandel outlines the evolution of deserved rewards and punishments from early religious paradigms to the current secular market system, where good choices are rewarded with an increased ability to consume and bad choices are punished with diminished consumption. Even in the nominally objective and secular system, there is a pervasive moral aspect of judgment. If we are in the land of opportunity, and we have done so much to bring equality of opportunity, then anyone who is less successful must have chosen their fate. Instead of success as a reward for good deeds, success has become a signal of moral virtue or goodness.
Sandel acknowledges that social mobility was a tool that helped to compensate for the inherent inequality of market outcomes. While the mechanism of mobility required an individual to make choices in line with market forces and the good fortune to be able to access the mechanisms of mobility, there was a chance to change the level of social esteem. Social mobility in the modern era is almost nonexistent. The refrain that people can and should be able to go as far as their talent and hard work can take them continues to echo in political discourse, but in practice has become less realistic.
A lack of upward social mobility means that the cost of moving down the socioeconomic scale is significant and has generational impacts. The widening gap between those with a college degree and those without further exacerbates the risk. Sandel identifies this as one of the dominant reasons for the Varsity Blues admissions scandal. Parents concerned that admission to a non-elite college or university would lead to less favorable outcomes for their children pulled any lever they could, while maintaining the illusion that their child earned a place in the admitted student body. To merit a position is evidence of good; to be given a position due to external factors is to remove the signaling value of the elite institution.
Admission to elite universities has become more competitive. Low acceptance rates are a badge of honor, and selectivity increases the perceived signaling value of an institution. The practical values, such as access to alumni networks or the potential for legacy advantages in admissions, are also undeniable. Sandel notes that he has observed a lasting impact on the students who have been admitted through the increasingly rigorous gauntlet, where they are likely to perceive their admission as an individual achievement and continue to search for validation through competition. The mental and physical health harms of the stress of unending competition, even aside from participation in recreational activities, Sandel challenges the concept of admission as a singularly personal achievement and proof of merit. Seemingly objective measures, such as test scores or high school grades, are influenced by socioeconomic status. Other résumé-building experiences or assistance in crafting an application strategy are also influenced by socioeconomic status, regional availability, and other barriers to access. Family members, teachers, coaches, and other influential figures contribute to developing the student who is admitted. Talent in areas that are rewarded in the admissions process is distributed through chance. This isn’t an argument that admission to an elite institution is something that is not worth celebrating, but instead a reexamination of what is being celebrated.
A dominant theme throughout The Tyranny of Merit is the importance of the dignity of work. In this context, dignity of work captures the social esteem from contributing to society and the bonds formed through that contribution. Sandel argues for a measure that relies not only on market valuation of an individual’s contribution, but one that also includes contribution to the moral common good of society. This is admittedly more difficult to measure as it requires debate and compromise to develop a definition of the common good, but doing so would help to restore non-economic rewards of work.
Tyranny of Merit highlights flaws in common arguments for meritocracy, and challenges how deeply the concept runs in our society. It encourages readers to examine their own perspective on merit, common good, and representations of success, sometimes in uncomfortable ways. There will be no fast or simple solution to the resentment fostered through meritocracy, but the first step is to examine how we as individuals and as participants in higher education contribute to the potential ills and rewards of the system.
This work of political philosophy is not a how-to manual, and there are few proposed interventions that could be implemented at the scale of an individual or at a single institution. I believe that this book will be most suited for readers who are involved in assessing and reshaping policies and processes, or who would like to be part of those discussions. It would serve well as an anchor for discussions about institutional philosophy, and in dialogue with other methods to evaluate potential policy gains and harms.

share