Tierney, W. G. 2021. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. 310 PP.

The purpose and significance of Higher Education for Democracy is to position its reader to examine their own role in higher education. As enrollment management professionals, we can appreciate that we do a fair amount of ‘good’ in our roles. We embrace that when our initiatives expand access to education, we are transforming the well-being and quality of life for individuals and communities. Yet, Tierney posits that challenges facing higher education brought upon by globalization and neoliberalism threaten the ability that higher education has to facilitate democracy. As numerous contemporary reports show, from Freedom House to V-DEM to the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, democracy is in decline across the globe. Higher Education for Democracy challenges its reader to re-imagine what higher education may need to look like so that we no longer take for granted the democracy we live in that enabled us to do our ‘good work’. Essentially, the future of higher education and democracy is under threat, and now is the time for action.

Given the theoretical arguments Higher Education for Democracy makes, Tierney unpacks abstract concepts into personal vignettes and reflections on his own experience in academia in three metropolitan locations: Los Angeles, New Delhi, and Hong Kong. Thus, Higher Education for Democracy offers its reader a global and humanist perspective. In doing so, Tierney embraces interpretive methods—a methodological design that focuses on understanding subjective experiences, meanings, and cultural contexts—to make his claims and further his argument. This lends Higher Education for Democracy to be a rich text weaving narrative into theory, and establishing a compelling argument that describes what is actually transpiring instead of what a model expects to happen.

Across seven chapters, Higher Education for Democracy considers distinct and interwoven crises facing higher education. Tierney unpacks the relationship democracy has with higher education, and how neoliberalism and globalization have created tension. Put simply, Tierney posits that if the core mission of higher education is to teach, research, and serve, then that is best accomplished in a democracy, because democracies will embrace knowledge to solve societal challenges and create well-being for society. Yet, when global powers coalesced around the utilitarian outcomes neoliberalism promised, this brought about societal, economic, and political inequality, privatization, and nationalism. Higher education was not exempt, leaving it to embrace a playbook that establishes efficiency, optimization, and growth as institutional and structural priorities. Under that playbook, policies and norms surrounding higher education increasingly defined it as a private good—focusing on revenue optimization, rankings, and proliferating credentialing, etc., with students adopting consumerist attitudes to inform their behavior. Across subsequent chapters unpacking the role of identity, the extent of academic freedom and speech, and the role of modern universities, Higher Education for Democracy seeks to make clear that when the playbook for higher education shifted, it also redirected attention away from what really matters—the democratic imperative of higher education interconnected with its mission as the vector of knowledge production and dissemination.

For enrollment management professionals, this poses a moment of reflection and examination instead of debate. I encourage skeptical readers to reserve judgment until the last page, and let the totality of Tierney’s claims and argument sink in. In its later chapters, Higher Education for Democracy offers strategic considerations that higher education can affirm (or reject) to solidify its role in society and facilitate democracy. These strategic considerations reflect the capacity for Higher Education for Democracy to be the canary in the coal mine of higher education. I encourage the reader not to consider these as comprehensive—they are merely a starting point.

Considering Contemporary Trends in Higher Education

Given the timing of its writing and publication Higher Education for Democracy could not have anticipated two contemporary trends that have enveloped our work—generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) and post-affirmative action policies. Briefly, I aim to address each of these trends, and acknowledge how Higher Education for Democracy may encourage us to think about them.

GenAI seems to be everywhere—in meetings about workflows, in conversations about staff productivity, or in decisions about future-looking investments. There is no mistaking the impact of GenAI. A recent empirical analysis by Liu and Wang found that the “top 40 [AI] tools received nearly 3 billion monthly visits in March 2024 from 200+ economies” (2026, 1).

In 2023, a pair of Supreme Court decisions effectively prohibited affirmative action policies in higher education. The effect was felt immediately as higher education institutions raced to comply with the court order. In doing so, higher education institutions made epistemic decisions about whose identities were seen, centered, and validated.

These two contemporary trends, seemingly disparate, are interconnected when considering them in context of Higher Education for Democracy. Tierney dedicates Chapters 3 and 4 to discussing the role of identity, and academic freedom and speech. Why? Because the idea of a university centers around the exchange of ideas—a phenomenon that also occurs in a democracy. Yet not all universities or democracies are the same nor created equal. It is entirely necessary to consider who has been permitted to exchange ideas, whose voice is heard first or most, and how the exchange of ideas is facilitated. Tierney considers that a university, just like a democracy, is a place to engage with communities forged through differences. Yet, both GenAI and post-affirmative action policies are successful in limiting communities of difference. This is due to GenAI being devoid of lived experience but emboldened with bias, and post-affirmative action policies explicitly blinding us from considering the effects and impacts of humans’ social construction of race. Essentially, if we get to a point where we are unsure of who we exchange ideas with and distrust that community can be formed through difference, then the idea of the university (and democracy) is further harmed.

Reading Recommendations

In recommending Higher Education for Democracy, I challenge the reader to consider the following:

  • For Enrollment Management Leaders: Read and unpack this book with a trusted faculty member in your institution’s political science program. Ask yourself—how does my institution’s enrollment strategy solve for the crises facing higher education? How might the decisions I make that are lauded in the near-term create unintended harm to future generations?
  • For Enrollment Management Practitioners:Tierney, W. G. 2021. AlbAny, ny: STATe UniverSiTy of neW york PreSS. 310 PP. A central challenge that Tierney posits is that we have the power to shape the future of higher education. Ask yourself—what do I want modern higher education to look like for students, colleagues, communities, etc.? What type of culture exists at my institution, and does that culture align with a higher education institution for democracy? Why/why not?
  • For Faculty: add this book to your required reading for graduate students. Think and discuss whether higher education institutions can achieve their potential under political, economic, and social conditions that reflect fascism.

Author

  • AACRAO Fallback Img

    Nicholas Rejebian

    Assistant Director of Strategic Initiatives in the Office of Admissions at the University of Cincinnati

Related Posts