The U.S. Education Department's inspector general warned the Trump administration in a semiannual report to Congress earlier this year against the agency's proposal to eliminate the gainful employment rule without other accountability standards in place.
Inspector General Kathleen Tighe, who retired from the department as of November 30, also warned House and Senate education committee leaders earlier this year against eliminating the rule in an overhaul of the Higher Education Act, reported Inside Higher Ed. In the new report, Tighe said the for-profit college sector "continues to be a high-risk area for the department," adding that it needs "particular accountability."
"OIG resources devoted to postsecondary school investigations continue to be disproportionately devoted to fraud and abuse in the proprietary sector," she wrote. "The sector also represents a disproportionate share of student loan defaults."
The report also found that the Education Department failed to meet targets to reduce improper payments through the Pell Grant program and that the department has not shown that it only recognizes accreditors that meet federal standards.
The agency announced plans in August to rescind the Obama-era gainful employment rule, which targets for-profit colleges over concerns about fraud and abuse in the industry. The controversial regulation, originally issued in 2011, was overturned in 2012 by a federal judge, prompting a revision of the rule that was stalled last year by the Trump administration. In place of the rule, the department proposed to hold institutions accountable solely by publishing information about student debt burdens, loan repayment and other data on the College Scorecard website.
The Trump administration, however, missed the deadline to finalize its proposal to repeal the gainful employment rules this year. Thus, pushing the implementation date back to July 2020 at the earliest. Meanwhile, an inter-agency dispute over data-sharing has already effectively killed the regulation, according to Politico. Agency officials confirmed they remain unable to produce the data needed to gauge the performance of colleges under the rule. The Social Security Administration, which must provide the earnings data, will not agree to renew an information-sharing agreement with the Education Department that expired in May.
Related Links
Inside Higher Ed
https://www.insidehighered.com/quicktakes/2018/12/04/inspector-general-faults-education-department
Politico
https://www.politico.com/newsletters/morning-education/2018/12/05/data-dispute-effectively-kills-gainful-rule-442906